Why Investing in an Executive Condo May Not Be Worth It

by | Apr 10, 2023

Many Singaporeans aspire to own executive condominiums (ECs) due to their affordability and potential capital appreciation. However, recent developments have shown that buying an EC may not be a sure-win investment after all. This article will delve into the reasons behind this change in perspective and what homeowners should consider before taking the plunge into purchasing an EC.

Market timing plays a crucial role in executive condo profitability

As previously discussed, executive condos (ECs) are not always guaranteed profit when it comes to selling. Market timing plays a crucial role in EC profitability, as seen in the analysis of past transactions. While some ECs have yielded significant profits, others have resulted in losses. This is because the housing market is subject to fluctuations, and the timing of a sale can greatly impact the selling price. Therefore, it is important for prospective buyers to carefully consider market conditions and their financial situation before making a purchase. While ECs may offer some benefits, such as government grants and access to private facilities, it is not always a sure-win investment.

EC popularity stems from the allure of upgrading to private property

One of the main reasons for the popularity of executive condominiums (ECs) among buyers is the desire to upgrade to private property. ECs are essentially subsidized private condos, with the government providing financial assistance to developers during the development stage. After 5 or 10 years of the EC’s completion, it is fully privatized and owners can reap the benefits of owning a private condo, without the hefty price tag. This allure of eventual privatization has led many first-time buyers to invest in an EC as a stepping stone to private property ownership. However, it is important to note that market timing and location play crucial roles in determining the profitability of an EC investment.

Price growth for leasehold condos is stronger than for nearby ECs

As mentioned earlier, price growth for Parc Centros, a leasehold condominium, is stronger than for two nearby ECs. While ECs may have the allure of upgrading to private property, it is important to consider the potential financial gains. It seems that in this case, leasehold condos may be a better investment option. Market timing also plays a crucial role in executive condo profitability, so it’s important to do thorough research before making a decision. However, it’s worth noting that ECs are significantly cheaper and eligible for government grants, with facilities reasonably equivalent to private condos. Furthermore, after 5/10 years of TOP, ECs are treated as private condos. It’s ultimately up to the individual buyer to weigh the pros and cons of purchasing a leasehold condo versus an EC.

Not all executive condos guarantee financial gains

While executive condos (ECs) are popular among buyers due to the allure of upgrading to private property after 5/10 years, not all ECs guarantee financial gains. Market timing plays a crucial role in the profitability of ECs, and price growth for leasehold condos can even be stronger than for nearby ECs. However, ECs remain significantly cheaper and are eligible for government grants. Facilities in ECs are reasonably equivalent to private condos, and after 5/10 years of TOP, ECs are treated as private condos. First-hand owners of privatized ECs have been sitting on considerable gains. Nevertheless, leaving an EC empty for five years is inferior to buying a private condo. Lenders are also very careful when giving out loans for condos, making it more difficult to purchase than a single-family home.

ECs are significantly cheaper and eligible for government grants

As mentioned earlier, executive condos (ECs) are popular among middle-income Singaporeans for a reason. Not only are they relatively cheaper than private condos, but first-time EC buyers can also receive up to S$30,000 in government grants. These CPF housing grants make owning an EC even more affordable, which is why newly launched ECs tend to be oversubscribed. However, it’s important to note that not all ECs guarantee financial gains and market timing plays a crucial role in their profitability. Nonetheless, EC facilities are reasonably equivalent to private condos and after the minimum occupancy period has lapsed, they are treated as private property. Additionally, first-hand owners of privatized ECs have been known to sit on considerable gains. Overall, while buying an EC is not a guaranteed win, it offers a great investment opportunity for those who plan accordingly.

EC facilities reasonably equivalent to private condos

Executive condos (ECs) offer a hybrid of public and private housing. While they are subsidized by the government, they are developed and sold by private developers, offering similar amenities to private condos at a more affordable price point. In fact, the facilities in ECs are reasonably equivalent to those found in private condos, making it a great option for those who want to upgrade but cannot afford to jump straight into private property. Additionally, after 5/10 years of TOP, ECs are treated as private condos, further increasing their value. ECs offer a unique opportunity for buyers to enjoy condo-like living at a more accessible price point, without sacrificing on amenities.

After 5/10 years of TOP, treated as a private condo

After five or ten years from the TOP (Temporary Occupation Permit) date, executive condominiums (ECs) are treated as private condos. This means that owners no longer have to adhere to HDB rules and can sell or rent out their units to anyone, regardless of citizenship or income level. This added flexibility is another advantage of owning an EC, making it a popular option for those who want to upgrade from HDB flats to private property. EC facilities are reasonably equivalent to private condos, and after fulfilling the five-year minimum ownership, owners can enjoy the perks of living in a private property without breaking the bank. While market timing and location play a crucial role in profitability, privatized ECs have shown considerable gains for their first-hand owners. Overall, owning an EC may not guarantee financial gains, but it still offers an affordable and attractive option for those looking to upgrade their housing situation.

First-hand owners of privatized ECs sitting on considerable gains

As mentioned in previous sections, first-hand owners of currently privatized ECs are sitting on considerable gains. This is based on historical data and highlights the potential profitability of owning an executive condominium. However, it’s important to note that not all ECs guarantee financial gains and market timing plays a crucial role in their profitability. Nonetheless, those who have purchased a privatized EC can enjoy the benefits of owning a private property while still being eligible for certain government grants. Additionally, after the 5 or 10-year Minimum Occupancy Period (MOP), ECs are treated as private condos, further increasing their value. Overall, while there are no guarantees in the property market, owning a privatized EC can be a profitable investment for first-hand owners.

Leaving an EC empty for 5 years is inferior to buying a private condo

While buying an executive condo may seem like a good investment, leaving it empty for the first five years could prove to be an inferior decision compared to buying a private condo. This is because private condos are sold as private properties from the start, while ECs are under HDB rules for the first ten years of ownership, which means owners have to fulfill a Minimum Occupation Period (MOP) of 5 years before they can rent it out or sell it on the open market. During this five-year period, the EC owner is unable to earn rental income, which could offset the mortgage and other expenses associated with the property. Additionally, private condos often appreciate value more quickly than ECs, which can mean a higher return on investment in the long run. While ECs are indeed cheaper and eligible for government grants, buyers should carefully consider the potential financial gains before committing to a purchase.

Buying a condo differs from purchasing a single-family home

When it comes to buying a condo, it’s important to understand that it differs greatly from purchasing a single-family home. One major difference is the cost – condos are typically more affordable than single-family homes. However, owning a condo also comes with additional costs, such as monthly maintenance fees and special assessments. Condo owners also have less control over their living environment, as they must abide by the rules and regulations of the homeowners’ association. On the flip side, condos often offer convenient and low-maintenance living options, with amenities such as pools, fitness centers, and on-site security. Ultimately, it’s important for buyers to carefully consider their lifestyle and financial goals before deciding whether to buy a condo or single-family home.